Sunday, December 22, 2019

A641.5.3.RB - Shorter_R ICT at the Team Level

Intentional Change Theory in the group setting describes five discovery stages that effective groups navigate as they form and sustain. Multiple iterations may exist within each discovery stage, and how each group handles the positive and negative emotional affecters can determine the success of the groups. The concept is illustrated in the different outcomes between the Women's United States Soccer Team and the United States Men's basketball team in 2000 and 2004.  In sports, why teams win and lose can be analyzed down to the smallest detail, but such explanations cannot necessarily be proven. However, I believe some elements within ICT may lend an answer. Boyatzis (2006) states, "Intentional change theory (ICT) is a complex system. At the individual level, ICT describes the essential components and process of desirable, sustainable change in one's behavior, thoughts, feelings, and perceptions. The change may be in a person's actions, habits, or competencies. It may be in their dreams or aspirations. It may be in the way they feel in certain situations or around certain people. It may be a change in how they look at events at work or in life" (p.609).

A team in any sport at any level all want to win. Both the men's basketball and women's soccer teams shared the same vision, goal, and ideal: to win. Although sharing the same ideals is a crucial component to the intentional change of a group, it does not necessarily equate to accomplishing a group's shared goal. Akrivou, Boyatzis, and McLeod (2006) discuss Tuckman's linear-progressive model in which the four stages of group development are proposed: forming, storming, norming, and performing. They postulate that "In the forming stage, testing becomes the key concern of groups. In the storming stage, resistance to both group influence and task requirement is shown. In the norming stage, resistance and conflict are overcome. In the performing stage, the interpersonal structure becomes the tool through which group energy is channeled into the task with results enhancing group performance" (Akrivou et al., 2006, p. 693). I think it is safe to surmise that each of these teams was in different stages of group development. The women's soccer team spent a considerable amount of time together before the Olympics, which probably put them further along in development. Whereas, the men's basketball team formed only months before the Olympic games began. Akrivou et al. (2006) also discuss group development in relation to intentional change and how it emerges through a series of five discoveries.

The five stages of discovery are:

 1:The emergence of shared ideal, vision, or dream.-Dorrance offered the team hope and a dream using teaching them a unique style of soccer. It became their trademark, which they rallied around as individuals and as a team.
2: "Exploration of norms, paradoxes, challenges, and gaps. This phase serves as a reality check in the group and creates the tension, experienced as the gaps or threats to the accomplishment of the shared ideal" (Akrivou, Boyatzis, McLeod, 2006). Dorrance selected players who would continue to train for an entire year on their own without the advantage of area gyms for support and motivation. They needed to be self-driven and motivated. "We had to find the sort of women that had this discipline, when no one cared about them or their game, to get out there and do some work and reach their potential on their own" (Halloran, N.D.). Selecting players for their passion as well as their skill is essential to maintain motivation. "The motivational force for salient and sustainable change comes from the group member's desires to evolve in the desired direction of the group level of the Ideal Self" (Akrivou, Boyatzis, McLeod, 2006).

3: The group's learning agenda-the group develops a learning agenda that focuses on the commitment to change goals and action steps. April Heinrich was appointed to head coach of the woman's U.S. soccer team in 2000. Her philosophy for player selection was to ensure they were sound psychologically to handle the pressure of the game and physically. The men's team did not take the time to learn about each other, and how they would work together, they were not solidified as a group or functioning team.
 4: The group is involved in experimentation and practice with new behavior or norms, consistent with their learning agenda. Heinrich's actions at times were considered harsh, and some players rebelled. Eventually, they rallied their commitment and succeeded, adjusting to the new coach's expectations.
5: Resonant relationships -When everyone can't be a superstar, there is a development and understanding of the relationships between group members, and learning that takes place in the role of each of the member's place in the group. The shared mission goes without saying, the take-back dominance of the sport and return to the top of the game. Leading and winning by example is undoubtedly a shift in paradoxes and overcoming challenges and gap bridging, by changing team philosophy.
The women's loss is more difficult to explain. They played together for quite some time and seemed to be well into the latter stages of group development and discovery. Many even blamed the loss on a poor call from a referee that resulted in the opposing team's winning goal.            Regardless of what level visions or shared visions may be, such as individual, team, or organizational level, those visions may be individual or shared are cultivated to invoke motivation moving from an ongoing state to the final desired state. Sometimes in sports, there may be what appears as an explanation for losing or valid reasons for not performing, and sometimes there is simply no explanation.  Intentional change on a team level can only be sustainable and effective if the members within that team find balance and cohesion between their shared visions and motivators. Without these shared foundations, lasting intentional change becomes difficult, if not impossible.

References:

Akrivou, K., Boyatzis, R. E., & McLeod, P. L. (2006). The evolving group: Towards a prescriptive theory of intentional group development. The Journal of Management Development, 25(7), 689-706.

Boyatzis, R. E. (2006). An overview of intentional change from a complexity perspective. Journal of Management Development,25(7), 607-623. doi:10.1108/02621710610678445

Holleran, A. (2016). When the united states last lost in men's basketball. Retrieved from http://thespun.com/news/united-states-basketball-loss-olympics

No comments:

Post a Comment